Calcium chaos


Imagine that I'm planning to build a wall of bricks. I start by throwing cement at a pile of bricks, hoping that it forms a nice, orderly brick wall.

Fat chance, you say.

I believe that is what appears to be emerging as the situation with calcium supplementation.

A recent study from New Zealand reported an experience with 1,471 postmenopausal women, mean age of 74 years, who were randomized to treatment with either calcium supplements or placebo. Calcium was supplied as calcium citrate (Citrical) to provide 1000 mg of (elemental) calcium per day (400 mg morning, 600 mg evening).

(Bolland MJ, Barber PA, Doughty RN et al. Vascular events in healthy older women receiving calcium supplementation: randomised controlled trial. Brit Med J BMJ, doi:10.1136/bmj.39440.525752.BE; published 15 January 2008)

Over 5 years, women taking calcium had twice the risk of having a heart attack compared with women taking the placebo; women taking calcium had a 47 percent higher risk of having any one of three "events" (heart attack, stroke or sudden death) than women in the placebo group.

The findings of this study run counter to what we've been telling people all these years: Calcium supplementation, usually taken to halt deteriorating bone health and osteoporosis, modestly reduces blood pressure, reduces LDL and raises HDL cholesterol. At first blush, we might thereby presume that it also reduces cardiovascular events.

This study suggests that calcium supplementation does not result in reduction of cardiovascular events, perhaps even increases risk.

Certainly, this new finding will serve to confuse the public even more than it is already, particularly when it comes to strategies that modify risk for heart attack. However, this may make more sense once we stop and think for a moment.

Calcium supplementation inarguably slows, occasionally halts, calcium resorption from bone (through suppression of parathyroid hormone). Calcium also accumulates as part of atherosclerotic plaque in coronary and other arteries.

How does oral calcium know where to go--bones, not arteries or kidneys, in addition to serving all its other crucial functions?

Keep in mind that, in many roles, calcium is passive, something that responds to control exerted by some other factor. Vitamin D is that factor. Vitamin D controls the absorption of calcium in the intestinal tract (calcium aborption quadruples when vitamin D is restored to normal), it controls whether calcium is deposited in bone or extracted from arteries. It is the master control over the fate of calcium. Calcium just goes along for the ride.

Bone and arterial health do indeed intersect via calcium, but not through calcium supplementation. Instead, the control exerted by vitamin D (and vitamin K2, another conversation) connects the seemingly unrelated processes.

At what calcium dose threshold do the benefits stop and the adverse effects begin? That remains unanswered, particularly in light of this new study. However, this study calls into serious question the wisdom of supplementing calcium at a dose of 1000 mg, particularly when taken without normalization of vitamin D.

Calcium is therefore emerging as an important player in artery health. But just taking calcium makes no more sense than our brick wall and cement analogy. You might regard vitamin D as the mason that skillfully lays down both brick and cement in a neat, orderly way.

Comments (30) -

  • Anne

    1/23/2008 7:47:00 AM |

    Dear Dr Davis,

    Sometimes I think I must be living in the Matrix - I thought this article so interesting as I have been prescribed calcium supplements for osteoporosis, but just a few weeks ago I had to stop taking them because I discovered they were the cause of severe diarrhoea I had been having for nearly a year. Stopping the calcium supplements halted the diarrhoea straight away, trying it again, even a different make, brought it back even on low dose. Anyway, it was just then that I read a lot about vitamin D3 on your blog and Dr Eades, just at that very time, so I upped my D3 intake to 5,000iu in the hopes it will help me absorb as much of my dietary calcium as possible. I cannot take dairy products so I get my calcium from leafy green veggies, nuts, seeds and fish. And now you wrote on your blog to look at vitamin D3 for aortic valves (I'm the one with bicuspid aortic valve) too. The Matrix ! Or I've found the best doctors on the internet Smile

    all the best,
    Anne

  • Anonymous

    1/23/2008 5:23:00 PM |

    I'm taking Vit D3 in gel form for my bones, heart, and to help prevent cancer, until it warms up here so I can get some sun. I'll be getting plenty of direct sun while gardening and bike riding, but the rest of the time outside, I'll sit in the the shade so I won't get too much UVA, since my family had a few skin cancers (caught early).

    I'm going to look for natto when I finally make it to the Asian store. I've heard it tastes pretty bad for people that have never eaten it, so I'll have to try to mix it in with something else probably. I've also read that some people compare it to blue cheese, so maybe I'll start with blue cheese recipes to try to mellow the natto taste.

    S

  • Red Sphynx

    1/23/2008 6:50:00 PM |

    Granted, calcium supplements leave a lot to be desired.

    But this article didn't cast any light on the problem.  Read Sandy Szwarc' excellent Fisking of this study over at JunkFoodScience.

    Adam Becker Sr

  • Anonymous

    1/23/2008 8:53:00 PM |

    Doesn't calcium compete with magnesium for absorption from the gut?  In which case, supplemental magnesium in addition to the calcium would be indicated

  • Anonymous

    1/24/2008 12:49:00 AM |

    I am so confused about this whole chotesterol/ heart attack risk argument. I've been reading your blog for months now and follow everything you say because it sounds like it all makes great sense. So whats the problem? We keep hearing more and more that total cholesterol, as was once thought, is not a very good indcator of impending heart attack. So how come Dr.William Castelli, the one time director of the famous Framingham Study says in over 60 years following thousands of people, they have NEVER had a heart attack in ANYONE with a total cholesterol below 150 regardless of what the HDL may be? If that doesn't indicate that total cholesterol CAN be a strong indicator I don't know what can. I understand if your cholesterol is higher than 150 this may not tell you anything, but for those of us below doesn't it? Or does no heart attacks in a 60 year period with thousands of people tell us nothing?

  • Dr. Davis

    1/24/2008 2:44:00 AM |

    I do not agree with Dr. Castelli's observation. I have seen MANY heart attacks with total cholesterols <150 mg/dl. I do not understand the discrepancy.

    For instance, an HDL of 23 mg/dl--very high risk--can easily be concealed within a low total cholesterol, as can smoking, diabetes, and Lp(a).

  • Peter

    1/24/2008 9:05:00 AM |

    Anonymous, even the most cursory glance at any of the aggressive LDL-C lowering trials will give you the information about the accuracy of Dr Castelli's statement. Let's not be too explicit.

    Peter

  • donnyrosart

    1/24/2008 1:33:00 PM |

    It looks like going into the study, the authors suspected the opposite (calcium prevents heart disease) was true. They mention speculation that calcium supplementation might be heart healthy by increasing malabsorption of fat, and quote a study where calcium supplementation doubled fecal fat and bile. Personally, I try to eat things I'd like to absorb.
    The first study they reference to (I think it's their own study) showed calcium supplementation increased Hdl, and decreased ldl, but had no effect on triglycerides. If ldl decreases, but triglycerides remain the same, does that suggest anything about ldl particle size?
    Really like your blog.

  • Dr. Davis

    1/24/2008 4:19:00 PM |

    Good question.

    I've not looked specifically for a LDL size effect from calcium, nor am I aware of any specific literature to this effect. However, I do believe that many of us are trending towards less and less calcium supplementation, particularly in light of vit D supplementation.

  • Anonymous

    1/24/2008 7:59:00 PM |

    I apologise maybe I worded my question incorrectly. Dr. Castelli doesn't claim that if you have a total cholesterol under 150 you will not have a heart attack, he says in The Framingham study ( involving 3 generations and over 10,000 people ) there has never been one. I suppose we could blow this off and claim he's lying ( I doubt it ) or try to learn something from it. Thats a VERY large long lasting study and once again he has said "under 150 REGARDLESS of HDL score" there HAS to be a reason for this, I was just wondering if anyone had a guess.

  • brittany lady

    1/24/2008 10:59:00 PM |

    This now has me totally confused.  My doctor recommended I take 1,000 mg. of Calcium in supplement form every day, and to make sure I get 800 mg. of Vitamin D.  I have done so faithfully plus drinking about 10 oz. of calcium added Lactaid fat free milk. I also learned after an x-ray, stress test and heart imaging that I have calcification at the base of my aorta, but my heart is not enlarged.  This has happened since 1999, and I have only been taking Vitamin D for the past year and a half. Now I wonder if large doses of Calcium before having my vitamin D levels tested might have caused this. On another note, I had very high triglycerides and started taking 2000 mg. of fish oil capsules daily.  My triglycerides dropped from 375 to 160 in 6 months.  That might be a solution to someone with these concerns.

  • Anne

    1/25/2008 8:23:00 AM |

    Since being diagnosed with osteoporosis last year I have done a lot of research on it and on various therapies. I am, btw, only 54 so it was a big shock. Anyway, looking at things logically, there is no way that someone my age would have got osteoporosis from lack of calcium, so why do they prescribe it ? It seems based on research done on elderly ladies in nursing homes. I've got osteoporosis because of health issues when I was younger yet, I was still told the usual to take 1000mg calcium and 800iu vitamin D. I refused bisphosphonates and have been prescribed Strontium Ranelate instead. I hope Strontium doesn't cause calcification, I don't think they know enough about it so I feel rather a guinea pig. Now that I can't tolerate calcium and have stopped taking it and upped the Vitamin D3 to 5000iu I feel more confident that this will help not only my bones but also my heart health. I also take 2,000mg of fish oil.....my triglycerides are currently 0.6 (53).

    Anne

  • Anne

    1/25/2008 1:39:00 PM |

    Something else to make one realise that calcium may not be as important as we have been told - if you look at countries in Africa where some people have sub-optimal diets and low in calcium, you usually don't often find osteoporosis ! I would hazard a guess that the reason they don't get osteoporosis is because they have plenty of Vitamin D from the sunshine and they probably do a lot of physical work.

    Anne

  • Dr. Davis

    1/25/2008 1:51:00 PM |

    Great thought.

    I am impressed that many of the "holes" in our thinking about health and nutrients is filling in with greater understanding of the role of vitamin D.

  • Rick

    1/25/2008 5:19:00 PM |

    Dr. Castelli also made the following observation:

    "For example, in Framingham, Mass, the more saturated fat one ate, the more cholesterol one ate, the more calories one ate, the lower the person’s serum cholesterol."

    For Dr. Eades's typically insightful take on the issue, go here:

    http://tinyurl.com/2d7bzw

    and here:

    http://tinyurl.com/24uqj2

  • Dr. Davis

    1/26/2008 5:05:00 AM |

    I couldn't agree more.

    Cholesterol (total and LDL) are lousy predictors of heart disease. They are, indeed, factors. But in the long list of factors causing heart disease, cholesterol is way down.

    But cholesterol is, no doubt, the most profitable. Revenues for statin drugs topped $27 billion last year.

  • Anonymous

    1/26/2008 3:05:00 PM |

    Great articles Rick, read them both and found them quite interesting however a little disappointed neither had anything to do with why after 60 years and following over 10,000 people NOT ONE of them with a total cholesterol under 150 ever had a heart attack. I eat low carb, loved Taubes book explaining the myths about eating fat, big proponent of Track your plaque and think Dr. Davis is brilliant and well ahead of his time. And yet either we think Dr. Castelli is a liar or anybody with ANY interest in preventive cardiology would want to know why no heart attacks in anyone with tot cholesterol under 150 in over 60 years in such a large group of people. My god we hear all the time about the stunning results of the HATS Trial which included a grand total of 161 people.

  • MAC

    1/26/2008 5:38:00 PM |

    Dr. Davis,
        Found this study while perusing Science daily today. Not sure how or if this intersects at all with the good results you get with Vit D.

    Vitamin D Deficiency May be a Sympton of Disease: Supplementations may make it worse:

    http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases
    /2008/01/080125223302.htm

    "Low blood levels of vitamin D have long been associated with disease, and the assumption has been that vitamin D supplements may protect against disease. However, this new research demonstrates that ingested vitamin D is immunosuppressive and that low blood levels of vitamin D may be actually a result of the disease process. Supplementation may make the disease worse."

  • Dr. Davis

    1/27/2008 2:18:00 AM |

    It refers to the so-called "Marshall Protocol." Having read his arguments, he mixes science with conjecture and enormous leaps of speculation, all with zero experience in real, live humans. (He's a "bench" researcher with experience that doesn't extend beyond mice and cell cultures.)

    It reminds me an awful lot of the pseudo-scientific tangent that misled Linus Pauling and Mathias Rath.

  • Rick

    1/27/2008 7:40:00 AM |

    Anonymous,

    No need to be disappointed.  Here's the relevance.  Dr. Eades quoted Dr. Kannel, who preceded Castelli as director of the Framinham study as saying:

    "...it is not possible to select a critical lipid value that separates potential CHD candidates from the rest of the population."

    That appears to contradict the implications of Castelli's quote.

    Dr. Eades also made the case that sometimes the pronouncement of the researchers is not supported by the evidence.

    What percent of the population had cholesterol lower than 150?  What was their age distribution?  These would be important things to know.

    In looking at a graph of the distribution, it appears that less than 5% of the population were in that category.  

    BTW, can you you provide a citation for your quote of Dr. Castelli?  Thanks.

  • Stan

    1/27/2008 3:32:00 PM |

    anonymous,

    Castelli said that there was no heart attack at all in the sub-population below 150mg/dl of cholesterol, and he said also
    that, quote:

    "For example, in Framingham, Mass, the more saturated fat one ate, the more cholesterol one ate, the more calories one ate, the lower the person’s serum cholesterol."

    This is a speculation but one possible explanation behind those two seemingly contradictory informations is that the
    subpopulation of people who had naturally low cholesterol in Framingham, were all young and/or  were all eating more animal fat and less carbohydrates than the other groups!  Younger people are more active and eat more calories too. Both factors (young age and a higher animal fat lower carbohydrate nutrition) tend to associate with low cholesterol
    and are simultanously cardioprotective.

    Is it improbable? I dont' think so. Dr. Davis's own results on vitamin D3 and essential fatty acids supplementation (naturally present in animal food, dairy, eggs, meat and fish!) also seem to point in the same direction.

    It would also fit another observation: I remember some published data on Masai population who also have or had very low total cholesterol (I think about 160 mg/dl on average), follow a high fat low carbohydrate nutrition and have very little heart disease!

    Stan (Heretic)

  • Anonymous

    1/28/2008 3:38:00 PM |

    http://tinyurl.com/24uqj2, Rick try this one but any search on google brings many citataions.

  • Anonymous

    1/28/2008 3:41:00 PM |

    Rick heres another better one.http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3987/is_20070409/ai_n19031299/pg_2

  • Rick

    1/29/2008 12:32:00 AM |

    Anon,

    Thanks for the links, but the first one is the link I gave you, and the second is truncated.  

    If it's the article by the chiropracter, I've already seen that, but was hoping for  a primary source so I could read the context.  I've done a fair amount of googling but haven't been able to find it.

    Your quote speaks of 60 years of research, yet the artcle you cite (at least I think it's the same artcle) speaks of 40 years and the Framingham website is proudly celebrating 50 years of research.

    This is not to nitpick but it does make me wonder if this isn't one of those internet quotes that takes on a life of its own.

    I agree with you that it is confusing because so much of what I have read, along with my own experience renders his observation, whether true or not, meaningless.

  • Anonymous

    1/29/2008 12:51:00 AM |

    http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3987/is_20070409/ai_n19031299/pg_2
    This article explains Dr. Castelli's position well.

  • Anonymous

    1/29/2008 12:55:00 AM |

    http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_qa3987/is_20070409/ai_n19031299
    Read this one Rick.

  • Anonymous

    1/30/2008 3:07:00 PM |

    The Framingham Study was begun in 1948. That seems to be the one point that is a fact.

  • Rick

    1/30/2008 7:14:00 PM |

    Thanks for the link.  That is one of the articles I'd already seen. ( Not to put too fine a point on it, but he does refer to 40 years, not 60 as in your quote.)

    The data I've seen confirms his statement.  People whose TC was below 150 didn't evidence CHD.  But, as I mentioned above, the number of those people was extremely small, less than 5% of the population. It may be true the nobody who's run a sub 2:10 marathon has suffered a heart attack, but so what?

    For the vast majority of the population in the study, those between 150 and 370, some did have CHD, some didn't.  The correlation was not strong except on the edges.  

    So what can we take away from this?  Get your TC below 150 and you're immune from CHD?  The same research shows correlation with low levels of TC and all cause mortality.  So choose your poison.

    And if, despite your best efforts, your numbers creep up above 150, are all bets off?  My TC over the years, has ranged from 140 to 180, most recently 160, yet my plaque burden put me in the 50th percentile for my peer group.  So the importance of Dr. Castelli's observation is lost on me.

    As pointed out by Dr. Davis, and many others, total cholesterol alone is not a very useful indicator. Check out the post on the Vytorin study. Those whose cholesterol dropped the most experienced a greater increase in plaque.

    So, while Castelli's statement is based in fact, there is a lot of room for interpretation.  And most of the rest of what is attributed to him in that article is speculation.

    Yes, Framingham was begun in 1948, but I doubt the data is available instantaneously.

  • Anonymous

    6/4/2008 1:31:00 PM |

    My sister and I got in argument at a picnic about whether calcium supplements are a good idea.  Afterward she sent me an article in favor, and I sent her one against.  Then I realized you wrote both articles!

  • ccruby

    8/17/2008 1:30:00 AM |

    Mayo Clinic diagnosed me with fluid around my heart.  I could feel it sloshing around.  Stopped calcium/mag and estrogen supplements and I could no longer feel it; I also kept telling it to go away.  Went back a couple of months later for MRI--Mayo said I had fat around my heart.  I know the original diagnosis was correct.

Loading

An exercise in optimism

Followers of the Track Your Plaque program already know that maintaining an optimistic viewpoint is important in gaining control over coronary plaque.

In fact, I believe that, in many cases, a sense of optimism may make or break your CT heart scan score-reducing efforts. Pessimists rarely drop their score, while optimists do so all the time.

This week posed a challenge to my optimism. I spent the last week on jury duty hearing the details of a murder case. For four days, I listened to blow-by-blow testimony about the totally pointless, unprovoked death of a young man by a drug-dealing thug. Much of the witness testimony was from people who shared the hopeless, violent world of the defendant.

I was, however, completely impressed by the dedication of the prosecuting attorney, a 50-some year old man who was clearly deeply dedicated to his mission and didn't once provide any indication that he was grandstanding or looking for some personal glory. He was doing his job and trying to obtain justice for the fallen victim. I was equally impressed by the judge, who seemed unfazed by the events but carefully explained why the system worked the way it did. After the trial, he provided some further insights to us jury members and I saw him as a human being who, like the prosecutor, was trying to make a small contribution to making the world better.

Though many of the witnesses who testified against the defendant shared his world, I was impressed with their courage in coming forward. They face the threat of reprisals, I'm sure, for coming forward to the law and testifying against a known career criminal. Several of them said that they were not after any reward, but simply wished to do the right thing and provide testimony that proved damning against the defendant.

I acted as the jury foreman and I was proud of how the jury members listened carefully, asked intelligent and probing questions, and then helped us render a confident and expeditious sentence: guilty.

If anything, despite the tragic circumstances, I was much heartened at how all the participants in this process played their part and justice (at least in the legal sense) was served.

Let optimism prevail, even in dire circumstances.

No need to re-invent the wheel

I seem to be repeating myself lately, but I think this does bear repeating:

There's no need to re-invent the wheel when it comes to gaining control over your heart scan score.

The Track Your Plaque program is the most powerful approach known to help you gain control over your coronary atherosclerotic plaque and CT heart scan score, bar none. While 100% of people do not drop their score, more and more people every week are doing so. (One of the admitted weaknesses of the Track Your Plaque website is our failure to list more success stories; we're working on it.)

The basic program is quite simple:

--The Rule of 60 for lipids (LDL 60 mg/dl; HDL 60 mg/dl or greater; triglycerides 60 mg/dl or less)

--Identify hidden causes of plaque, esp. small LDL, Lp(a), and IDL, followed by specific corrective action

--Fish oil--minimum 1200 mg per day of EPA + DHA

--Normal vitamin D3 blood levels (We aim for 25-OH-vitamin D3 of 50-60 ng/ml)

--Normal blood sugar (<100 mg/dl)

--Normal blood pressure (<130/80)

--An optimistic attitude



Much of the other stuff--vitamin K, matrix metalloproteinase reducing strategies, flavonoid strategies, exercise-induced hypertension, etc.--are, for the majority, fluff. Their real role is in people who may have failed in stopping the rise of their heart scan score just doing the basics of the program.

If you neglect the basics, hoping to find some magic potion, I'm afraid the overwhelming likelihood is that you will fail. I've seen it happen time and again. Someone will come to my office with an extraordinary list of supplements--hawthorne, dozens of anti-oxidants, EDTA, concentrated flavonoid preparations, and on and on. Not only is it shockingly expensive to do this, it's also unnecessary and foolhardy. This kind of unfocused, hocus-pocus in the hopes of getting it right fail time after time.

The Track Your Plaque program, while not foolproof, is the best I know of. Stick to the basics and wander off when the basics fail. But there's extraordinary power in just achieving the basics.

Are we a front for drug companies?

I was shocked recently when someone accused me and the Track Your Plaque website of being nothing more than a front for the drug industry, that we are promoting concepts with the hidden pharmacuetical agenda behind us.

Don't make me laugh. How in the world that kind of impression could be gotten from either the Heart Scan Blog or the Track Your Plaque website is beyond me.

But I occasionally do need to state explicity: We do not promote drugs, neither this Blog nor the Track Your Plaque website has ever sought nor been backed by pharmaceutical money. The only money that supports this website is our own and that from paying Track Your Plaque members.

In fact, I am quite proud of the unbiased content and commentary on both venues. I challenge anyone to point out how and where there is any suggested relationship to a hidden source of commercial backing. I assure you, there is none.

If I say a drug is worth you and your doctor considering, then I say so with a true belief in it, not because somebody or some company paid me to say so. If I say a drug stinks, I believe that too. If we use a specific supplement in the program, it's because we believe it truly adds value to a plaque-reversal program. We receive no money from drug, supplement, or other commercial interests to promote their products. Period.

What is "normal"?

When it comes to laboratory values and medical testing, a common dilemma is knowing what is "normal." Let me explain.

First of all, when you receive a laboratory result for a test, a "reference range" or "normal range" is usually provided. Where did that range come from?

It varies from test to test. For instance, a low potassium is easy, because low potassium levels can lead to life threatening consequences, e.g., dangerous heart rhythms. High potassium likewise, because dangerous phenomena develop when potassium generally exceeds 5.5 mg/dl or so.

But what about something like HDL or LDL. Here's where confusion reigns. Often, "normal" is obtained by taking the average and saying that any value plus or minus two standard deviations (remember that painful class?) represents normal or reference range.

If that were true, what if we applied that principle to body weight. If we weighed several thousand adult women, the average would be in the neighborhood of 172 lbs (no kidding). Does that mean that 172 lbs plus or minus two standard deviations is normal? No, of course not.

There is therefore a distinction between "normal" and "desirable". For HDL cholesterol, your laboratory report might say that an HDL cholesterol of 40-60 mg/dl is normal. But is it desirable? I don't think so. The most frequent HDL level for a male with a heart attack is 42 mg/dl--hardly desirable.

Let's take triglycerides. The average triglyceride level in the U.S. is somewhere around 140 mg/dl. For those of us who do a lot of lipoprotein testing, we can tell you that triglycerides at this level, though generally regarded as being within the normal range, are associated with flagrant and obvious excesses of several abnormal lipoprotein particles that contribute to coronary plaque growth (VLDL and often IDL; small LDL; drop in HDL and shift towards small HDL).

So, always take the so-called "normal" or "reference" values on a lab report as crude guidelines that often have little or nothing to do with health or desirability. Unfortunately, many physicians are not aware of this and will declare any value within the normal or reference range as okay. An HDL of 40 mg is not okay. A triglyceride level of 140 mg is also not okay.

What is okay? What is desirable? That depends on the parameter being examined. From a basic lipid standpoint, of course, we regard desirable as 60-60-60. Desirability from a lipoprotein standpoint we will cover in a more thorough Track Your Plaque Special Report in future.

The wisdom of the masses

My sister sent me these quotes:



"We don't like their sound, and guitar music is on the way out."

Decca Recording Co. rejecting the Beatles, 1962


"Stocks have reached what looks like a permanently high plateau."

Irving Fisher, Professor of Economics, Yale University, 1929


"Airplanes are interesting toys but of no military value."

Marechal Ferdinand Foch, Professor of Strategy, Ecole Superieure de Guerre, France


"Everything that can be invented has been invented."

Charles H. Duell, Commissioner, US Office of Patents, 1899



No doubt, conventional wisdom can often be laughably (tragically?) wrong. The problem is that, as absurd as all the above sentiments seem to us now and in retrospect, they represented the view of many people years ago. These views were held by many, including many people in positions of power and decision-making responsibility.

A more relevant but nonetheless laughable and widely held belief in 2007: coronary heart disease should be treated with hospital procedures.

Why is a disease that requires 30 years to develop treated only at the final moments with a procedure? Do you only change your car's oil when the engine is on its last legs? Or, do periodic, relatively effortless oil changes during the life of the car make better sense?

I witness just how brainwashed the public has become with this crazed notion when I meet someone socially at, say a fundraiser or cocktail party. When they ask what I do, I tell them I'm a cardiologist. The invariable response: "Oh, what hospital do you work out of?"

I tell them I don't, that I take care of the majority of heart disease right from the office. 99% of the time I get a puzzled look. If we had comic bubbles above our heads revealing our internal thoughts, it would read "Yeah, right. What a kook."

The notion that coronary heart disease is something that is manageable with simple tools for the majority of us in the early stages is entirely foreign to almost everybody. The hospitals and the medical industry have so succeeded in dazzling the public with images of staff in scrubs, rushing from emergency to emergency, lights flashing, scalpels flying. . . how can you possibly accomplish this at home or anywhere outside of the high-tech world of the hospital?

Well, I'm a cardiologist and I do it every day. We all need a figurative dose of electroshock therapy to shake ourselves of this crazy notion.

How important is l-arginine?

Perhaps more than any other supplement, l-arginine causes frustration and confusion. It’s difficult to find, sometimes quite expensive, and some preparations cause loose stools.

Just how necessary is it?

L-arginine, you’ll recall, is a source of nitric oxide, or NO. Though it’s the same stuff as in car exhaust, NO provides a critical signaling role in your body’s cells that regulate a multitude of functions. Among the important roles of NO is to powerfully dilate, or relax, arteries. A constant flow of NO is required for health, particularly since each molecule persists only a few seconds.

L-arginine is the body’s source of nitric oxide. In addition, a peculiar but very effective blocker of l-arginine called asymmetric dimethylarginine, or ASDM, has recently been discovered to prevent the production of NO. Varied conditions like hypertension, diabetes, high cholesterol, excessive saturated fat or processed carbohydrate intake all lead to heightened levels of ASDM, often several-fold greater levels, and thereby effectively blocking NO production.

The “Arginine Paradox” is the name that some researchers in this field have given to the unusual property of l-arginine supplementation to “overpower” the blocking effects of ASDM. This is somewhat unusual in biologic systems in that an agent that blocks a receptor cannot usually be outmuscled by providing excess material for a reaction. Kind of like hoping that your car runs faster simply by topping up the gas tank.

Concrete observable benefits have been made for l-arginine in clinical trials, such as arterial relaxation that results in arterial enlargement (which can actually be seen in the cath lab); anti-inflammatory effects; reduction of blood pressure; enhancement of insulin responses, etc. All of these effects can be connected to beneficial properties that may facilitate atherosclerotic plaque regression and, indeed, there are limited data to document that this is true.

Drug companies may be greedy, but they’re not stupid. They’ve been vigorously pursuing this line of research for some years, a research path that led inadvertently to the erectile dysfunction agent, sildenafil (Viagra), and all its subsequent competitors. (Erectile dysfunction is another expression of endothelial dysfunction, since male erections are driven by the ability to dilate penile arteries.) The wonderful properties of NO enhancement continue to occupy research labs around the world.

Wow. So what’s the reluctance? In the early years of the Track Your Plaque program (meaning just a short 7-8 years ago), I was thoroughly convinced that l-arginine was a crucial, necessary part of a plaque regression program. Without it, you would rarely succeed. With it, the odds were tipped in your favor.

However, something curious has emerged recently. I’ve seen more and more people dropping their heart scan scores. Not just a little bit, but a huge amount. Witness our most recent record holder, Neal, who dropped his score 51% in 15 months. Just five years ago, this magnitude of reversal was unimaginable. Granted, Neal is our record holder, but others are obtaining 10, 18, 24, 30% drops in scores all the time. Many have done it without l-arginine.

Now, how about the people who have failed to stop a rising score? Would they do better with l-arginine as part of the mix? I believe so, but sometimes we never quite know except in retrospect. It has been a great dilemma for us trying to predict from the starting gate who will or who won’t drop their heart scan score.

My view from the trenches is that l-arginine packs its greatest atherosclerosis-fighting punch in the first year or two of use, when “endothelial dysfunction” is likely to be present (abnormal artery constriction). But as all other strategies take hold—fish oil, correction of lipid and lipoprotein abnormalities, weight loss (big effect), vitamin D (another very big effect), etc.—endothelial behavior improves over time. Perhaps l-arginine becomes a less necessary component over time.

There’s no doubt that uncertainty still surrounds the use and science surrounding l-arginine. However, if you’re interested in stacking the odds in your favor, particularly during the first year or two of your plaque-reducing efforts, I think that l-arginine is worth considering. It is cumbersome, it can be expensive, some preparations may even be foul. But in the big picture of life, with hospitals trying every possible ploy to get your body on a table for a procedure, doctors perverting their mission by signing employment contracts with hospitals and agreeing to usher you into the hospital as a paying patient whenever possible, and drug companies viewing you and me as a market for medications which may or may not be helpful, l-arginine is surely not that big a burden.

Track Your Plaque and non-commercialism

If you're a Track Your Plaque Member or viewer, you may know that we have resisted outside commercial involvement. We do not run advertising on the site, we do not allow drug companies to post ads, we do not covertly sponsor supplements. We do this to main the unbiased content of the site.

We've seen too many sites be tempted by the money offered by a drug company only to see content gradually drift towards providing nothing more than cleverly concealed drug advertising. I personally find this deceptive and disgusting. Ads are ads and everyone knows it. But when you subvert content, secretly driven by a commercial agenda, that I find abhorrent.

That said, however, I do wonder if we need the participation of some outside commercial interests to help our members. In other words, many (over half) of the questions and conversations we have with people is about what supplement to take, or what medication to take. While we cannot offer direct medical advice online (nor should we) because of legal and ethical restrictions, I wonder if could facilitate access to products.

Many people struggle, for instance, with trusted sources for l-arginine, vitamin D, fish oil. Other people struggle with finding a heart scan center because of the changing landscape of the CT scanning industry. Could we somehow provide a clear-cut segment of the website that clearly demarcates what is commercial and non-Track Your Plaque-originated, yet at least provides a starting place for more info?

Ideally, we would have personally tried and investigated everything there is out there applicable to the program. But that's simply impossible at this stage.

I feel strongly that we will never run conventional ads on the site. Nor will we ever permit any outside commercial interest to dictate what and how we say something. The internet world is full of places like that. Look at WebMD. I find the site embarassing in the degree of commercial bias there. We will NEVER sell out like that, regardless of the temptation. People with heart disease are all conducting a war with the commercial forces working to profit from them--hospitals, cardiologists, drug companies, medical device companies (yes, even they advertise to the public, e.g., implantable defibrillators--no kidding). Genuine, honest, unbiased information is sorely needed and not from some kook who either knows nothing about real people with real disease, or has a hidden agenda like selling you chelation.

I'd welcome any feedback either through this Blog or through the contact@cureality.com.

The nattokinase scam

A conversation about vitamin K2 commonly leads to confusion. Several people have asked about something called nattokinase.

The scientific data on the potential role of vitamin K2 deficiency in causing both osteoporosis and vascular calcification is fascinating. Along with vitamin D3, vitamin K2 may be an important factor in regulation of calcium metabolism. Supplementation may prove to be a major strategy for inhibition of vascular calcification.

Obtaining K2 in the diet is tricky, since it's present in just a handful of foods: egg yolks, liver, traditional cheeses, and natto. This is where the confusion starts.

Natto is a Japanese fermented soy product. I've had it and it's quite disgusting. Nonetheless, Japanese who eat natto experience less fracture. (A parallel study in heart disease has not been performed.) Natto is also a source of another substance called nattokinase.

Advocates (otherwise often known as supplement distributors) claim that nattokinase is a "fibrinolytic", or blood clot-dissolving, preparation that "improves blood flow, protects from blood clots, and prevents heart attacks and strokes."

Don't you believe it. This is patent nonsense. There are several problems with this rationale:

--Any oral fibrinolytic agent is promptly degraded in the highly acid environment of the stomach. That's why all medically used fibrinolytics are given intravenously. Drug companies have struggled for years to encapsulate, modify, or somehow protect protein (or polypeptide) products taken orally from degrading this way. They've never succeeded. That's why, for instance, growth hormone (a polypeptide) remains an injection, not an oral agent. An oral growth hormone, by the way, would sell like mad, so the drug companies would very much like to figure out how to bypass the degradative effects of stomach acid. One of the "researchers" behind the nattokinase claims boasts that he has single-handedly figured out how to protect the nattokinase molecule in the gastrointestinal tract. However, he won't tell anybody how he does it. Right.

--Fibrinolytic agents are extremely dangerous. In years past, we used to treat heart attacks with intravenous fibrinolytic agents like tissue plasminogen activator, urokinase, streptokinase, and others. They have fallen by the wayside, for the most part, because of limited effectiveness and the unavoidable dangers of their use. Fibrinolytics are "dumb": they dissolve blood clots in both good places and bad. While they might dissolve the blood clot causing your heart attack, they also degrade the tiny clot in your cerebral (brain) circulation that was protective. That's why fatal brain hemorrhages, bleeding stomach ulcers, and blood oozing from strange places can also occur with fibrinolytic administration. Believe me, I've seen it happen, and I've watched people die from them.

The idea that a small dose taken orally is healthy is ridiculous. Even if nattokinase worked, why the heck would you take an agent that has known dangerous and very real consequences?

Don't let this idiocy reflect poorly on the K2 conversation, which, I believe, holds real merit and is backed by legitimate science. This is symptomatic of a larger difficulty with the supplement industry: Insane and unfounded claims about one supplement erodes credibility for the entire industry. It gives regulation-crazed people like the FDA ammunition to go after supplements, something none of us need. You and I have to sift through the nonsense to uncover the real gems in this rockpile, real gems like vitamin D3, omega-3 fatty acids from fish oil, and, perhaps, vitamin K2. But not nattokinase.

Blood pressure with exercise

Here's a frequently neglected cause for an increasing CT heart scan score: High blood pressure with exercise. Let me explain.

Paul's blood pressure at rest, sitting in the office or on arising in the morning, or at other relatively peaceful moments: 110/75 to 130/80--all in the conventional normal range.

We put Paul on the treadmill for a stress test. At 10 mets of effort (on the protocol used, this means 3.4 mph treadmill speed at 14 degree incline), Paul's blood pressure skyrockets to 220/105. That's really high.

Now, blood pressure is expected to increase with exercise. If it doesn't rise, that's abnormal and may, in fact, be a sign of danger. Normally, blood pressure should rise gradually in a stepwise fashion with increasing levels of exercise. But any blood pressure exceeding 170/90 is clearly too high with exercise. (Not to be confused with high blood pressures not involving exercise.) A handful of studies have suggested that a "breakpoint" of 170/90 also predicts heightened risk of heart attack over a long period.)

I see this phenomenon frequently--normal blood pressure at rest, high with exercise. This also suggests that when Paul is stressed, upset, in traffic congestion, under pressure at work, etc., his blood pressure is high during those periods, as well. I wouldn't be surprised to see other phenomena of underappreciated high blood pressure, like abnormally thick heart muscle (left ventricular hypertrophy), an enlarged thoracic aorta (visible on your heart scan), left atrium, perhaps even an abnormal EKG or abnormal kidney function (evidenced by an elevated creatinine on a standard blood panel).

Unfortunately, the treatments that reduce blood pressure are "stupid," i.e., they have no appreciation for what you are doing and they reduce blood pressure all the time, whether or not you're stressed, exercising, or sleeping.

Blood pressure reduction should begin with weight loss, exercise, reduction of saturated fats and processed carbohydrates (esp. wheat), magnesium replacement, vitamin D replacement. Think about CoQ10. After this, blood pressure medication might be necessary.

The message: Watch out for the blood pressures when you have a stress test. Or, if you have a friend who is adept at getting blood pressures, get a blood pressure immediately upon ceasing exercise. It should be no higher than 170/90.

Vitamin D2 vs. vitamin D3

An interesting question came up on the Track Your Plaque Member Forum about vitamin D2 vs. vitamin D3. This often comes up among our patients, as well.

Vitamin D is measured in the blood as 25-OH-vitamin D and is distinct from 1,25-diOH-vitamin D, a kidney measure, a test you do not need unless you have kidney failure.

The human form of vitamin D is cholecalciferol and is usually obtained via activation of a precursor molecule in the skin on activation by the sun. You can also take cholecalciferol and it increases blood levels of 25-hydroxy vitamin D reliably.

However, there is a cheap, plant-sourced, alternative to vitamin D3, called vitamin D2, or ergocalciferol. D2 has far less effect in the body. Taking D2 or ergocalciferol orally is an extremely inefficient way to get D. Unfortunately, it's the form often used in milk and many supplements, even the prescription form of D. About half the multivitamins and calcium supplements I've looked at contain ergocalciferol rather than cholecalciferol.

Taking vitamin D2 yields very little conversion to the effective D3. This particular issues is maddening, as the USDA requires dairy farmers to add 100 units of vitamin D to milk, and D2 is often used. In other words, the D in many dairy products barely works at all. There are many children who rely on D from dairy products who are at risk for rickets and are not getting the D they need from dairy products because of this cost-saving switch. Do not rely on milk for vitamin D for your children.

D2 or ergocalciferol is often included in the blood measures of vitamin D along with vitamin D3. The only reason it's checked with blood work is to ensure "compliance,", i.e., see whether or not you're taking a prescribed ergocalciferol. Beyond this, it has no usefulness.

25-OH-vitamin D3, or cholecalciferol, is both the blood measure and the supplement you need. This is the one that packs all the punch. Keep in mind also that it is the oil-based gelcap you want, with more consistent and efficient absorption. Tablets usually barely work at all, even if it contains cholecalciferol. Most people who take calcium tablets with D, or multivitamin with D, not only are getting a powdered form of D, but also in trivial doses. It's the pure vitamin D3, cholecalciferol, in gelcap form you want if you desire all the spectacular benefits of vitamin D.